Viewing your Watchlist and recommended content requires Javascript

  • 15
  • Drama
  • 2013
  • 153 mins

Prisoners

Film4 Prisoners

Synopsis

When his six-year-old daughter and her seven-year-old friend mysteriously vanish on Thanksgiving Day, Pennsylvania carpenter Keller Dover (Hugh Jackman) takes the law into his own hands.

About

It's no surprise that Aaron Guzikowski's original screenplay for Prisoners languished on The Black List, a register of inexplicably unfilmed scripts, for some time. It features elements seldom found in formulaic Hollywood studio projects: complicated characters, ambiguous motives and serious moral dilemmas. It's less of a surprise that French-Canadian film-maker Denis Villeneuve, whose award-winning 2010 film Incendies possessed all these qualities in spades, chose this script for his first English-language feature. Or that having done so, he was able to attract a heavyweight cast of actors - Hugh Jackman. Jake Gyllenhaal, Maria Bello, Terrence Howard, Viola Davis, Paul Dano, Melissa Leo - to play both the leading parts and the more modest supporting roles.

Prior to the disappearance of his six-year-old daughter and her seven-year-old friend, Keller Dover (Jackman) was a hard-working blue collar guy who prayed for the best but prepared for the worst. A survivalist whose basement was stuffed with tinned food and emergency equipment, Dover lived by his father's maxim: be ready. But nothing had prepared him for a parent's worst nightmare. His wife Grace (Bello), numbed by grief and anti-depressants, berates him for not protecting his family. But Detective Loki (Gyllenhaal) is forced to release the chief suspect (Dano), a man in his twenties with the mind of a child, after only forty-eight hours. Knowing that his daughter's chances of survival are reducing with every passing hour, Dover abducts and tortures Alex, with the reluctant help of the other girl's father (Howard) and his passively complicit wife (Davis). Encouraging the audience to identify with the father's dilemma, Villeneuve's film poses the ethical question, How far would you go, and what might you be capable of?

Persistent rain and Roger Deakins' extraordinary, near-monochromatic cinematography establish a murky atmosphere, creating a sense of characters enveloped by a miasma of impotent rage, primal fear and nagging doubt. Villeneuve's emotionally charged direction draws the best from the actors, including the ever credible Melissa Leo as the suspect's over-protective aunt – a woman scarred by the disappearance of her husband and the earlier loss of her own son to cancer. Even so, Jackman overplays his portrayal of the ruthlessly pragmatic Dover; this contrasts starkly with Gyllenhaal's laser-focused portrayal of the meticulous Detective Loki, which reveals layer upon layer of subtle complexity. Sadly, there are echoes here of Clint Eastwood's Mystic River, whose dense plotting and thought-provoking seriousness were ultimately undermined by a reliance on residual generic trappings and audience gullibility – as exemplified here by a transparently ludicrous red herring and a credibility-stretching plot twist.

Cast & Connections

  • Actor: Jake Gyllenhaal, Maria Bello, Melissa Leo, Hugh Jackman, Paul Dano, Viola Davis, Terrence Howard
  • Director: Denis Villeneuve
  • Producer: Andrew A Kosove, Kira Davis, Broderick Johnson
  • Photographer: Roger Deakins

In a nutshell

A disturbing crime thriller, elevated by subtle storytelling, challenging ideas and fine performances, but let down by some lazy generic tropes and jarring implausibilities.

by Nigel Floyd

Latest from Film4...

  • Film4

    The Mortal Instruments: City of Bones

    Lily Collins stars in Harald Zwart's fantasy action-adventure, based on the first novel in Cassandra Clare's bestselling series for young adults.

  • Film4

    The Rise

    Luke Treadaway, Neil Maskell and Timothy Spall star in this Leeds-set heist caper, the debut feature from writer-director Rowan Athale.

  • Channel 4 Blog

    Channel 4 announces major increase to Film4 funding

    Film4 funding has increased to a record £25m in 2016, with major new deals announced with Fox Searchlight and FP Films. Film4 will be backing new work from Lenny Abrahamson, Yorgos Lanthimos, Andrew H

  • Channel 4 Blog

    The 36th London Film Critics Circle Awards

    The Film4-backed 45 Years takes Best Actor, Best Actress and Best British Film at the 36th London Critics' Circle Film Awards Other prizes for Film4-backed films included Breakthrough Filmmaker for d

Register with Film4.com

Personalise your Film4 experience

  • Set film reminders
  • Build your watchlist
  • Get film suggestions

or Register

Tweets @Film4

  • "Nobody ever gets to see what could have been." At 6.50pm, Zac Efron stars in The Death & Life of Charlie St. Cloud. https://t.co/IFrloAISux

  • RT @Bathfestivals: Neil Jordan #Oscar Winning Dir / Scr Writer /Author is at #BathLitFest https://t.co/JRS0tN4kMF @BathFilm @BathSpaUni htt…

  • RT @HOME_mcr: Join us for our 1hr intro to #HKCrimeFilms tomorrow at 6:30pm. This little audio taster should whet your appetite https://t.c…

  • RT @CentralPictureH: The most depraved double bill #CultureShock Cannibal Holocaust + The Green Inferno, Sat 13 Feb, 8pm! https://t.co/rgcN…

  • @IanThom61868878 Yep, directed by Mark Hartley (who did the ace Ozploitation doc Not Quite Hollywood).

Share