Viewing your Watchlist and recommended content requires Javascript

  • 18
  • Drama, World Cinema
  • 2013
  • 104 mins

Pietà

Film4

Synopsis

A merciless, sadistic debt collector (Lee Jung-jin)'s life changes when a woman claiming to be his mother (Cho Min-soo) enters his life in Kim Ki-duk's unsettling thriller.

About

Given that Korean auteur Kim Ki-duk’s eighteenth feature is a film with serious parental issues and a whiff of revenge thriller, it’s natural to assume that Pietà has the potential to be this decade’s Oldboy. Combine that enticing subject matter with the film’s bagging of the top prize at the 2012 Venice Film Festival, and expectations could hardly be higher. So while Pietà is undoubtedly intriguing, it's surprising – and a little disappointing - to find that it seems more interested in wilfully alienating its audience than in giving it anything meaningful to chew on.

Kang-do (Lee Jung-jin) is a 30-year-old loan enforcer who relishes violently crippling clients unable to pay the extortionate interest his employer charges. Out of the blue, Min-sun (Cho Min-soo) appears to Kang-do, explaining that she is the mother who abandoned him at birth and wishes to make amends. To describe their relationship as unorthodox is like describing the core of the sun as 'toastie': Kang-do's methods of testing Min-sun's truthfulness are horrific, yet she takes them in her stride, while Min-sun gladly offers Kang-do a helping hand in a situation where a man's mother is usually the last thing on his mind.

Kang-do is a deeply unpleasant creation: his barely concealed glee at torturing innocent people immediately marks him out as a wrong 'un, but Kim fills a large part of his film with repeated violent visits to hard-up clients to hammer (and drill) the message home. He even shows us Kang-do masturbating in his sleep: apparently a clear sign that he’s a deeply disturbed psycho. Hopes that he might, therefore, reveal interesting layers to his character at some point are dashed when it appears that he's like that simply because he was an abandoned baby. Likewise, the sea change his personality undergoes after the appearance of Min-sun is hard to swallow, and he becomes little more than a conduit for Kim to enact controversy-baiting acts which do little to further the plot or deepen the character.

When the truth about the relationship between Kang-do and Min-sun becomes clear it's a welcome (though not particularly inspired) twist in an otherwise pedestrian drama, but as Pietà's bizarre mother/son dynamic enters familiar territory it becomes, ironically, more entertaining but less interesting. Flashes of delicious black comedy alleviate the brutality, but unavoidable comparisons to Bong Joon-ho's Mother (2010) and Park Chan-wook's Vengeance trilogy reveal that Pietà isn't as nuanced or intelligent as either.

Cast & Connections

  • Director: Ki-Duk Kim
  • Screen Writer: Ki-Duk Kim

In a nutshell

Dark and twisted but without the depth to back it up, Pietà is determined to provoke controversy at the expense of characterisation. It's not without merit, but it's an uncomfortable watch as likely to offend as entertain.

by Neil Alcock

Latest from Film4...

  • Film4

    The Five-Year Engagement

    Jason Segel and Emily Blunt are Tom and Violet, a happy couple whose plans to marry become increasingly hopeless. Co-starring Chris Pratt and a host of sit-com favourites, expect sincerely romantic moments amongst Segel's signature frat boy humour.

    On Film4: 4 Aug 9:00PM

  • Film4

    Maidan

    Documentary portrait of the winter 2013/14 Ukrainian demonstrations in Kiev against the pro-Moscow presidency of Viktor Yanukovych and for a greater integration with Europe.

  • Film4

    Damsels in Distress on Film4

    Whit Stillman returns to directing, with a twee comedy that follows Greta Gerwig and her pompous college buddies as they set about improving campus life for all

  • Film4

    The Five-Year Engagement on Film4

    Jason Segel and Emily Blunt are Tom and Violet, a happy couple whose plans to marry become increasingly hopeless. Co-starring Chris Pratt and a host of sit-com favourites, expect sincerely romantic moments amongst Segel's signature frat boy humour.

Register with Film4.com

Personalise your Film4 experience

  • Set film reminders
  • Build your watchlist
  • Get film suggestions

or Register

Tweets @Film4

  • Evening! Your mission, should you choose to accept it, is to watch spy action sequel Mission: Impossible 2 @ 6.35pm. https://t.co/KisighEd5j

  • At 4.25pm, Nicole Kidman & Daniel Craig star in Philip Pullman's dark fantasy adventure The Golden Compass. https://t.co/q4dPRbK2eP

  • Afternoon, folks! At 2.40pm, we're off to Springfield to see Homer, Marge, Spider-Pig & co in The Simpsons Movie. https://t.co/GofwmmkNYg

  • RT @2000AD: First names in the credits: John Wagner and Carlos Ezquerra. Without whom none of this would have been possible. #Dredd

  • @enchantedbyfilm Oh, definitely. It's as personal in tone and style as any Burton-directed film. And it's amazing, too. Enjoy the marathon!

On Film4

  • Film4

    Damsels in Distress on Film4

    Whit Stillman returns to directing, with a twee comedy that follows Greta Gerwig and her pompous college buddies as they set about improving campus life for all

  • Film4

    The Five-Year Engagement on Film4

    Jason Segel and Emily Blunt are Tom and Violet, a happy couple whose plans to marry become increasingly hopeless. Co-starring Chris Pratt and a host of sit-com favourites, expect sincerely romantic moments amongst Segel's signature frat boy humour.

  • Film4

    The Impossible on Film4

    A true story made with the intimate involvement of the Spanish family, the Alvarez Belons, to whom it happened, The Impossible tells the story of a married couple (Naomi Watts, Ewan McGregor) and their three sons, who were holidaying in Thailand when the

Share