Killing Them Softly
A loose network of large, medium and small time professional crooks cross paths, seldom with happy consequences, in Chopper director Andrew Dominik's free market capitalism crime thriller
'Bleak' is a word that can cover a multitude of sins in filmmaking. It might mean joyless austerity. It might mean you can expect to finish the film feeling miserable and not much else. Or it might mean that we're in for a dose of misanthropy, and it's this last sense that most applies to Andrew Dominik's adaptation of George V. Higgins' 1974 novel Cogan's Trade. Killing Them Softly offers a highly misanthropic vision of humanity, but is nevertheless entertaining, with tremendous performances by the ensemble cast fleshing out already juicy low life characters.
Scoot McNairy and Ben Mendelsohn in particular make an excellent double act as Frankie and Russell, a pair of - not to put too fine a point on it - idiots who, as idiots so often do in noirish genres, get in over their heads with some dangerous people. Frankie (McNairy) is the more personable of the pair, and it's Frankie whose relative naivety will later contrast painfully with the man embodying this film's black heart: Brad Pitt in the small but pivotal role of professional enforcer Jackie Cogan, whose contribution to his marketplace is businesslike and brutal violence combined with lengthy speeches.
The bricks and mortar of the piece are standard cinematic thuggery and associated gangsterish preoccupations with hookers and drugs, elegantly photographed. But it's the cultural backdrop that the writer-director would presumably like to stand out as a point of difference compared your run of the mill genre flick, as media reports running throughout the talky yet visceral action draw parallels between financially motivated brutality and currently topical free market driven economic chaos. It won't win any points for subtlety but perhaps earns some credit for being here at all in a film that's otherwise mostly about watching men take each other apart and deliver diverting soliloquies brimming with self-justification.
Cast & Connections
- Actor: Richard Jenkins, Ben Mendelsohn, James Gandolfini, Scoot McNairy, Brad Pitt, Ray Liotta
- Director: Andrew Dominik
- Screen Writer: Andrew Dominik
- Photographer: Greig Fraser
In a Nutshell
Complex and problematic in a rather wonderful way, Killing Them Softly has flaws more interesting than some film's perfections, and would in any case be worth seeing for its performances alone, which are among 2012's most horribly fascinating.