Meryl Streep, Carey Mulligan and Helena Bonham-Carter star in Sarah Gavron's drama about the foot soldiers of the early feminist movement
Oscar-nominated documentary about Brazilian artist Vik Muniz's collaboration with employees of the world's largest rubbish dump.
An Oscar-nominated profile of a wealthy artist who sets out to improve the lot of an impoverished social underclass through creative outreach, set to a soundtrack by Moby, Waste Land sounds like the sort of film that should come with a smug do-gooder disclaimer before its opening credits. It will come as a pleasant surprise (to those unfamiliar with British director Lucy Walker's earlier films, at least) that the film that unravels is more self-conscious, subtle enquiry than the dubious bleeding-heart PR stunt implied by its premise.
The artist in question is Brazilian-born Vik Muniz, and the film tracks his portraiture project with a handful of the 3,000 odd catadores (or "pickers") who filter the contents of the world's largest rubbish dump, Jardim Gramacho in Rio de Janeiro. As in her 2006 documentary, Blindsight, which followed record-breaking blind mountaineer Eric Weihenmayer as he accompanied six blind Tibetan children up a 23,000ft peak neighbouring Everest, Walker openly questions the motives of her subject (as does Muniz himself) from the outset. One minute the artist is expressing doubt over his own presumptions - "Who am I to help?" ; the next, he's coolly discussing with a business associate the need for the Jardim Gramcho project to capture "the human factor" in order to succeed.
Whether the works themselves, mass-scale portraits of the catadores made from waste materials (filmed from above in time lapse sequences that inescapably call to mind some of Neil Buchanan's finest art attacks) make the grade is, of course, down to personal taste - though they reach tens of thousands at auction. Walker's film undoubtedly succeeds in Muniz's aim, though, largely through interviews with the catadores.
Their surprising, frequently harrowing anecdotes are as abundant and varied as their quarry - from the description of a teenage picker, already a mother herself, of the moment she found a baby's body discarded amongst everyday waste; to another's comparison of the rule of drug lords over contemporary favelas to the clout of private armies in Renaissance Florence (gleaned from his reading of Machievelli's The Prince, a garbage-soaked copy of which he salvaged from Gramacho). Trite as it inevitably sounds, it's the age-old triumph of the human spirit that chimes the loudest here, along with the voice of one particularly lively protester, responding to a fellow union member's suggestion that the catadores' go on hunger strike outside the local mayor's office: "I don't know about you guys, but I'm having lunch at noon!"
About as troubling as it is uplifting, Walker's film might not clock up as many layers of meaning as its literary namesake, but it's a damn sight more sophisticated than the one-note, arms-around-the-world Moby score which accompanies it.
"To me, the best part about being famous is taking down phonies..." As God Bless America receives its UK TV premiere on Film4, writer/director Bobcat Goldthwait (World¿s Greatest Dad, Willow Creek) lo
Editor Chris Wyatt has worked on modern classics of film and TV including Dead Man¿s Shoes, Dreams Of A Life and Dead Set. Here, he talks about his work with Yann Demange on ¿71, out now on DVD and B
Find out who voted for Film4.com's list of the top 100 must-see films of the 21st Century so far
A tooth-chattering voyage through the scariest movies ever made